The Men of P.S. I Love You

1 of 4

The Life of the Party

Three handsome -- and very different -- men vie for Hilary Swank's heart in P.S. I Love You. Each has his charms, but which one would you fall for? We asked relationship expert Dr. Judy Kuriansky (author of the Complete Idiot's Guide to Dating) to weigh in on the movie's real Mr. Right -- and Wrong.
P.S. We Love Them!

The Guy: Gerry (played by Gerard Butler)
Type: The Life of the Party. He's passionate about everything he does (karaoke included!) and has a blast doing it. All aspects of his life -- love, career, practical jokes -- are approached with the same fiery intensity.
Love him -- or leave him? "Most women are bedazzled by the alpha male. But the chances of a relationship surviving are poor. Although he'd show you a grand time, he's most likely a player and a flirt with other women," says Kuriansky. "Gerry is definitely a red light: Stop and think before getting involved."

Wild at Heart: Hilary Swank Opens Up

1 of 4